Keicho Ichibu Die Study now available!

The Rectangle Coins
The Rectangle Coins
  • Home
  • The Basics
  • Gold Set
  • Silver Set
  • ID Guide
  • Research Notes
    • Help!
    • Videos & Presentations
    • References
    • Gold Obverse Design
    • Gaku Ichibu Die Study
    • Keicho Ichibu Die Study
    • Shotoku Ichibu
    • Attributing Man'en Nibu
    • Counterfeit Shonai Ichibu
  • Contact Me
  • More
    • Home
    • The Basics
    • Gold Set
    • Silver Set
    • ID Guide
    • Research Notes
      • Help!
      • Videos & Presentations
      • References
      • Gold Obverse Design
      • Gaku Ichibu Die Study
      • Keicho Ichibu Die Study
      • Shotoku Ichibu
      • Attributing Man'en Nibu
      • Counterfeit Shonai Ichibu
    • Contact Me
  • Sign In

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • The Basics
  • Gold Set
  • Silver Set
  • ID Guide
  • Research Notes
    • Help!
    • Videos & Presentations
    • References
    • Gold Obverse Design
    • Gaku Ichibu Die Study
    • Keicho Ichibu Die Study
    • Shotoku Ichibu
    • Attributing Man'en Nibu
    • Counterfeit Shonai Ichibu
  • Contact Me

Account

  • My Account
  • Sign out

  • Sign In
  • My Account

Counterfeit Shonai Ichibu

In 2025, a friend of mine submitted a Shonai ichibu to PCGS that came back as "Counterfeit Altered Variety," indicating that the host coin was real but the Shonai stamps were countefeit. Upon closer inspection, not only did its stamps match my Shonai example exactly, but they matched most examples I've seen. He contacted the seller and found out they were no longer selling Shonai ichibu because they learned that many they'd sold in the past year had been modern counterfeits. They seem to be primarily coming out of Japan, often through eBay.


The stamps appear to be fairly consistent and easy to distinguish from genuine Shonai ichibu once you know what to look for.

Comparing Counterfeit and Genuine Stamps

Counterfeit

Graded MS63 in 2021, before the counterfeit stamps had been identified

Genuine

Graded MS63

Genuine

Genuine

Graded XF Details

庄 Stamp

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Genuine

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Genuine

Counterfeit

Genuine

The lines in the counterfeit 庄 stamp are very thick compared to genuine examples, and the edges are very clear and defined. Genuine pieces have thinner lines and are less evenly struck, with some edges being very vague. Additionally, all the lines in the countefeit 庄 stamp are the same width, while genuine examples have lines that taper and change thickness. The geunine 庄 stamp is also often seen placed more haphazardly on the coin; it's always to the right of the original coin text, but it may be closer to the top or bottom. Counterfeit examples are very consistently struck near 分.

Y Stamp

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Genuine

Counterfeit

Counterfeit

Genuine

Counterfeit

Genuine

Similarly, the counterfeit Y stamp is very chunky and tends to be very evenly struck. Genuine Y stamps typically have much thinner lines and are often struck unevenly, as seen in the center example.

  • Book Progress
  • Update Log

The Rectangle Coins

Copyright © 2025 Lianna Spurrier - All Rights Reserved.

No AI has been used in the creation of this site or the content herein.

Powered by